The ZIP package provides features not found in java.util.zip:
In addition to the information stored in ArchiveEntry a ZipArchiveEntry stores internal and external attributes as well as extra fields which may contain information like Unix permissions, information about the platform they've been created on, their last modification time and an optional comment.
ZIP archives store a archive entries in sequence and contain a registry of all entries at the very end of the archive. It is acceptable for an archive to contain several entries of the same name and have the registry (called the central directory) decide which entry is actually to be used (if any).
In addition the ZIP format stores certain information only inside the central directory but not together with the entry itself, this is:
This means the ZIP format cannot really be parsed correctly while reading a non-seekable stream, which is what ZipArchiveInputStream is forced to do. As a result ZipArchiveInputStream
ZipArchiveInputStream shares these limitations with java.util.zip.ZipInputStream.
ZipFile is able to read the central directory first and provide correct and complete information on any ZIP archive.
ZIP archives know a feature called the data descriptor which is a way to store an entry's length after the entry's data. This can only work reliably if the size information can be taken from the central directory or the data itself can signal it is complete, which is true for data that is compressed using the DEFLATED compression algorithm.
ZipFile has access to the central directory and can extract entries using the data descriptor reliably. The same is true for ZipArchiveInputStream as long as the entry is DEFLATED. For STORED entries ZipArchiveInputStream can try to read ahead until it finds the next entry, but this approach is not safe and has to be enabled by a constructor argument explicitly.
If possible, you should always prefer ZipFile over ZipArchiveInputStream.
ZipArchiveOutputStream has two constructors, one of them uses a File argument, the other uses an OutputStream. The File version will try to use RandomAccessFile and fall back to using a FileOutputStream internally if that fails.
If ZipArchiveOutputStream can use RandomAccessFile it can employ some optimizations that lead to smaller archives. It also makes it possible to add uncompressed (setMethod used with STORED) entries of unknown size when calling putArchiveEntry - this is not allowed if ZipArchiveOutputStream has to use an OutputStream.
If you know you are writing to a file, you should always prefer the File-arg constructor.
Inside a ZIP archive, additional data can be attached to each entry. The java.util.zip.ZipEntry class provides access to this via the get/setExtra methods as arrays of bytes.
Actually the extra data is supposed to be more structured than that and Compress' ZIP package provides access to the structured data as ExtraField instances. Only a subset of all defined extra field formats is supported by the package, any other extra field will be stored as UnrecognizedExtraField.
Prior to version 1.1 of this library trying to read an archive with extra fields that didn't follow the recommended structure for those fields would cause Compress to throw an exception. Starting with version 1.1 these extra fields will now be read as UnparseableExtraFieldData.
Traditionally the ZIP archive format uses CodePage 437 as encoding for file name, which is not sufficient for many international character sets.
Over time different archivers have chosen different ways to work around the limitation - the java.util.zip packages simply uses UTF-8 as its encoding for example.
Ant has been offering the encoding attribute of the zip and unzip task as a way to explicitly specify the encoding to use (or expect) since Ant 1.4. It defaults to the platform's default encoding for zip and UTF-8 for jar and other jar-like tasks (war, ear, ...) as well as the unzip family of tasks.
More recent versions of the ZIP specification introduce something called the "language encoding flag" which can be used to signal that a file name has been encoded using UTF-8. All ZIP-archives written by Compress will set this flag, if the encoding has been set to UTF-8. Our interoperability tests with existing archivers didn't show any ill effects (in fact, most archivers ignore the flag to date), but you can turn off the "language encoding flag" by setting the attribute useLanguageEncodingFlag to false on the ZipArchiveOutputStream if you should encounter problems.
The ZipFile and ZipArchiveInputStream classes will recognize the language encoding flag and ignore the encoding set in the constructor if it has been found.
The InfoZIP developers have introduced new ZIP extra fields that can be used to add an additional UTF-8 encoded file name to the entry's metadata. Most archivers ignore these extra fields. ZipArchiveOutputStream supports an option createUnicodeExtraFields which makes it write these extra fields either for all entries ("always") or only those whose name cannot be encoded using the specified encoding (not-encodeable), it defaults to "never" since the extra fields create bigger archives.
The fallbackToUTF8 attribute of ZipArchiveOutputStream can be used to create archives that use the specified encoding in the majority of cases but UTF-8 and the language encoding flag for filenames that cannot be encoded using the specified encoding.
The ZipFile and ZipArchiveInputStream classes recognize the Unicode extra fields by default and read the file name information from them, unless you set the constructor parameter scanForUnicodeExtraFields to false.
The optimal setting of flags depends on the archivers you expect as consumers/producers of the ZIP archives. Below are some test results which may be superseded with later versions of each tool.
So, what to do?
If you are creating jars, then java.util.zip is your main consumer. We recommend you set the encoding to UTF-8 and keep the language encoding flag enabled. The flag won't help or hurt java.util.zip prior to Java7 but archivers that support it will show the correct file names.
For maximum interop it is probably best to set the encoding to UTF-8, enable the language encoding flag and create Unicode extra fields when writing ZIPs. Such archives should be extracted correctly by java.util.zip, 7Zip, WinZIP, PKWARE tools and most likely InfoZIP tools. They will be unusable with Windows' "compressed folders" feature and bigger than archives without the Unicode extra fields, though.
If Windows' "compressed folders" is your primary consumer, then your best option is to explicitly set the encoding to the target platform. You may want to enable creation of Unicode extra fields so the tools that support them will extract the file names correctly.
In most cases entries of an archive are not encrypted and are either not compressed at all or use the DEFLATE algorithm, Commons Compress' ZIP archiver will handle them just fine. As of version 1.7, Commons Compress can also decompress entries compressed with the legacy SHRINK and IMPLODE algorithms of PKZIP 1.x.
The ZIP specification allows for various other compression algorithms and also supports several different ways of encrypting archive contents. Neither of those methods is currently supported by Commons Compress and any such entry can not be extracted by the archiving code.
ZipFile's and ZipArchiveInputStream's canReadEntryData methods will return false for encrypted entries or entries using an unsupported encryption mechanism. Using this method it is possible to at least detect and skip the entries that can not be extracted.
The traditional ZIP format is limited to archive sizes of four gibibyte (actually 232 - 1 bytes ≈ 4.3 GB) and 65635 entries, where each individual entry is limited to four gibibyte as well. These limits seemed excessive in the 1980s.
Version 4.5 of the ZIP specification introduced the so called "Zip64 extensions" to push those limitations for compressed or uncompressed sizes of up to 16 exbibyte (actually 264 - 1 bytes ≈ 18.5 EB, i.e 18.5 x 1018 bytes) in archives that themselves can take up to 16 exbibyte containing more than 18 x 1018 entries.
Apache Commons Compress 1.2 and earlier do not support Zip64 extensions at all.
Starting with Apache Commons Compress 1.3 ZipArchiveInputStream and ZipFile transparently support Zip64 extensions. By default ZipArchiveOutputStream supports them transparently as well (i.e. it adds Zip64 extensions if needed and doesn't use them for entries/archives that don't need them) if the compressed and uncompressed sizes of the entry are known when putArchiveEntry is called or ZipArchiveOutputStream uses RandomAccessFile (see above). If only the uncompressed size is known ZipArchiveOutputStream will assume the compressed size will not be bigger than the uncompressed size.
ZipArchiveOutputStream's setUseZip64 can be used to control the behavior. Zip64Mode.AsNeeded is the default behavior described in the previous paragraph.
If ZipArchiveOutputStream is writing to a non-seekable stream it has to decide whether to use Zip64 extensions or not before it starts wrtiting the entry data. This means that if the size of the entry is unknown when putArchiveEntry is called it doesn't have anything to base the decision on. By default it will not use Zip64 extensions in order to create archives that can be extracted by older archivers (it will later throw an exception in closeEntry if it detects Zip64 extensions had been needed). It is possible to instruct ZipArchiveOutputStream to always create Zip64 extensions by using the setUseZip64 with an argument of Zip64Mode.Always; use this if you are writing entries of unknown size to a stream and expect some of them to be too big to fit into the traditional limits.
Zip64Mode.Always creates archives that use Zip64 extensions for all entries, even those that don't require them. Such archives will be slightly bigger than archives created with one of the other modes and not be readable by unarchivers that don't support Zip64 extensions.
Zip64Mode.Never will not use any Zip64 extensions at all and may lead to a Zip64RequiredException to be thrown if ZipArchiveOutputStream detects that one of the format's limits is exceeded. Archives created in this mode will be readable by all unarchivers; they may be slightly smaller than archives created with RandomAccessFile in Zip64Mode.AsNeeded mode if some of the entries had unknown sizes.
The java.util.zip package and the jar command of Java5 and earlier can not read Zip64 extensions and will fail if the archive contains any. So if you intend to create archives that Java5 can consume you must set the mode to Zip64Mode.Never
Some of the theoretical limits of the format are not reached because Apache Commons Compress' own API (ArchiveEntry's size information uses a long) or its usage of Java collections or RandomAccessFile internally. The table below shows the theoretical limits supported by Apache Commons Compress. In practice it is very likely that you'd run out of memory or your file system won't allow files that big long before you reach either limit.
The java.util.zip package of OpenJDK7 supports Zip 64 extensions but its ZipInputStream and ZipFile classes will be unable to extract archives created with Commons Compress 1.3's ZipArchiveOutputStream if the archive contains entries that use the data descriptor, are smaller than 4 GiB and have Zip 64 extensions enabled. I.e. the classes in OpenJDK currently only support archives that use Zip 64 extensions only when they are actually needed. These classes are used to load JAR files and are the base for the jar command line utility as well.
Prior to version 1.5 ZipArchiveInputStream would return null from getNextEntry or getNextZipEntry as soon as the first central directory header of the archive was found, leaving the whole central directory itself unread inside the stream. Starting with version 1.5 ZipArchiveInputStream will try to read the archive up to and including the "end of central directory" record effectively consuming the archive completely.